Long-term variations in the plasma sheet ion composition and substorm occurrence over 23 years
© Nosé. 2016
Received: 6 December 2015
Accepted: 28 December 2015
Published: 13 January 2016
The Geotail satellite has been operating for almost two solar cycles (~23 years) since its launch in July 1992. The satellite carries the energetic particle and ion composition (EPIC) instrument that measures the energetic ion flux (9.4–212 keV/e) and enables the investigation of long-term variations of the ion composition in the plasma sheet for solar cycles 22–24. From the statistical analysis of the EPIC data, we find that (1) the plasma ion mass (M) is approximately 1.1 amu during the solar minimum, whereas it increases to 1.5–2.7 amu during the solar maximum; (2) the increases in M seem to have two components: a raising of the baseline levels (~1.5 amu) and a large transient enhancement (~1.8–2.7 amu); (3) the baseline level change of M correlates well with the Mg II index, which is a good proxy for the solar extreme ultraviolet (EUV) or far ultraviolet (FUV) irradiance; and (4) the large transient enhancement of M is caused by strong magnetic storms. We also study the long-term variations of substorm occurrences in 1992–2015 that are evaluated with the number of Pi2 pulsations detected at the Kakioka observatory. The results suggest no clear correlation between the substorm occurrence and the Mg II index. Instead, when the substorms are classified into externally triggered events and non-triggered events, the number of the non-triggered events and the Mg II index are negatively correlated. We interpret these results that the increase in the solar EUV/FUV radiation enhances the supply of ionospheric ions (He+ and O+ ions) into the plasma sheet to increase M, and the large M may suppress spontaneous plasma instabilities initiating substorms and decrease the number of the non-triggered substorms. The present analysis using the unprecedentedly long-term dataset covering ~23 years provides additional observational evidence that heavy ions work to prevent the occurrence of substorms.
The ion composition of plasma in the magnetosphere and the plasma sheet is one of important parameters in space physics, because it affects the Alfvén velocity that is a fundamental physical quantity of plasma. When plasma contains ion species heavier than H+, such as He+ and O+, the plasma mass increases to more than 1 amu and the Alfvén velocity decreases. For example, the plasma mass with 95 % H+ and 5 % O+ is 1.75 amu, and the Alfvén velocity in this plasma decreases to approximately 76 % of that in a proton only plasma. It is expected that various plasma phenomena are altered in such low Alfvén velocity environments. Another aspect of the ion composition change is that the plasma acquires multiple spatial scales corresponding to the gyroradii of ions or increases in the effective ion gyroradius. This may affect the threshold of plasma instabilities.
Thus, information on the long-term change of the ion composition in terrestrial plasma is crucial in studies of space weather or space climate. Previous studies using data of 2–7 years showed that the number densities or energy densities of He+ and O+ ions have a good correlation with the F10.7 index (e.g., Young et al. 1982; Stokholm et al. 1989; Lennartsson 1989; Pulkkinen et al. 2001). More recently, using data obtained by the energetic particle and ion composition (EPIC) instrument onboard the Geotail satellite, Nosé et al. (2009) studied the variations of the ion composition in the plasma sheet for more than 16.3 years (from 17 October 1992 to 21 February 2009) to confirm that the He+/H+ and O+/H+ flux ratios depend on the F10.7 index with stronger correlation for O+/H+.
The Geotail satellite continues observations after the study of Nosé et al. (2009) and accumulates ion flux data up to the present (as of December 2015) that cover almost two solar cycles and are very valuable for the study of long-term variations of the ion composition in the plasma sheet. In this paper, we expand upon the work of Nosé et al. (2009) by using longer-term and updated data from the Geotail/EPIC instrument. Although Nosé et al. (2009) used the F10.7 index to measure the long-term variations of solar activity, we adopt the Mg II index, because it is a better proxy for the solar extreme ultraviolet (EUV) or the far ultraviolet (FUV) irradiance that directly affects the ionospheric ion outflow. We also introduce a new scheme to identify the effect of ion composition on substorm occurrence by classifying the substorms into externally triggered or non-triggered events.
Geotail carries the EPIC instrument that can measure the energetic ion flux (9.4–212 keV) with mass and charge state information in almost full solid angle (~4π sr) (Williams et al. 1994). In this study, we use the omnidirectional flux integrated over this energy range (I a ), where a represents ion species (H+, He+, O+, and He2+). A more detailed description of how to calculate I a is given by Nosé et al. (2009). The data period is from October 1992 to October 2015, covering the declining phase of solar cycle 22, all of solar cycle 23, and the rising phase of solar cycle 24.
Mg II index
The Mg II index is derived from the ratio of the irradiance in the core of the Mg II emission around 280 nm (the h line at 279.56 nm and the k line at 280.27 nm) to the irradiance at neighboring wavelengths (Heath and Schlesinger 1986). The ratio is used to reduce problems due to variations in instrumental sensitivity. The Mg II index is not a direct measure of the solar EUV/FUV irradiance (i.e., 10–200 nm), but strongly correlates (c.c. = 0.96–0.99) with the solar EUV/FUV irradiance measured by the Solar EUV Monitor (SEM) or Extreme ultraviolet Imaging Telescope (EIT) on the Solar and Heliospheric Observatory (SOHO) satellite (Viereck et al. 2001; Floyd et al. 2005). The correlation coefficient between the F10.7 index and the EUV/FUV irradiance is 0.94–0.96, a little smaller than that for the Mg II index. Balan et al. (1994) reported that the EUV/FUV flux is saturated when the F10.7 index exceeds the threshold of ~150 sfu (solar flux unit, 1 sfu = 10−22 W/m2/Hz). Thus, the Mg II index provides a better proxy for solar EUV/FUV radiation than the F10.7 index.
The solar EUV/FUV radiation is absorbed in the terrestrial atmosphere at ~50–200 km altitude (Bowman et al. 2008) and affects the density and temperature of ionospheric ions. The long-term variations of EUV/FUV may control the supply of ionospheric ions into the space plasma and change the ion composition. In this study, we use the “Bremen composite” Mg II index (Snow et al. 2014) for January 1992 to October 2015 and compare them with the Geotail/EPIC observations.
Pi2 pulsation at low-latitude is considered a good proxy for the onset of substorms; thus, we identify Pi2 pulsations from the 1-s geomagnetic field data at Kakioka (27.5° geomagnetic latitude). The period of the 1-s data is from January 1992 to October 2015. Pi2 pulsations are selected in 2100–0100 magnetic local time by using the automated detection algorithm developed by Nosé et al. (1998).
Variations of plasma sheet ion composition for 23 years
Figure 1c–f display the variations of the integral fluxes of H+, He+, O+, and He2+ ions, which are averaged over 27 days corresponding to the synodic rotation period of the Sun. In the calculation of the 27-day averages, we remove the data segments when Geotail stayed in the magnetic lobe where the H+ integral flux is zero, because we are interested in the ion composition in the plasma sheet. The integral fluxes before March 1995 (open circles) are for the mid-tail plasma sheet at X GSM = −32 to −100 R E and Y GSM = −14 to 14 R E , and those after March 1995 (filled circles) are measured in the near-Earth plasma sheet at X GSM = −8 to −32 R E and Y GSM = −8 to 8 R E . It is natural that the former is smaller than the latter by approximately an order of magnitude, because the plasma becomes more tenuous as it moves farther away from the Earth. The integral flux in the near-Earth plasma sheet generally shows ~1-year periodical oscillations since March 1995, which is caused by the change of the Geotail location in X GSM , as seen in Fig. 1a. We also note the suppression of the integral flux around 2006–2012 during which the Z GSM of the Geotail location mostly shifts to negative values (Fig. 1b). This reflects the longer presence of Geotail in the off-central plasma sheet or boundary plasma sheet, where the flux is smaller than that in the central plasma sheet. In addition to these changes, both the He+ and O+ integral fluxes show long-term variations with timescale of more than 10 years, that is, gradual increases in 1995–2001 and 2010–2015, and a gradual decrease in 2002–2008. The long-term variations are more significant for O+ than He+.
Plasma ion mass
The results are shown in Fig. 1g. We find that M is around 1.1 amu during 1994–1997 and 2006–2010, whereas it increases to 1.5–2.7 amu during 1998–2004 and 2012–2015. The increases in M seem to have two components, that is, a raising of the baseline levels (~1.5 amu) and a large transient enhancement (~1.8–2.7 amu).
Variations of substorm occurrence for 23 years
Discussion and conclusions
From Figs. 3 and 5b, we find that the Mg II index, a proxy of the solar EVU/FUV, is correlated with the plasma ion mass in the plasma sheet (c.c. = 0.77) as well as the occurrence of the non-triggered substorms (c.c. = −0.46). We interpret this result to mean that (1) the increase in the solar EUV/FUV radiation raises the ionospheric ion density and temperature, enhances the supply of ionospheric ions (He+ and O+ ions) into the plasma sheet, and increases M; and (2) the large M (i.e., heavy plasma sheet) may suppress spontaneous plasma instabilities that lead to the onset of substorms and decrease the number of the non-triggered substorms. Although the physical mechanisms of the suppression of plasma instabilities are not identified in this study, the inverse relation is identified between M and the number of non-triggered substorm occurrence (Fig. 5c), which supports the second interpretation. The distribution of data points in Fig. 5c does not seem linear, but we find the linear correlation coefficient to be −0.37 that is statistically significant according to the correlation coefficient test of Bevington and Robinson (1992).
There has been a long discussion over the last 30 years about the role of heavy ions in substorm occurrence. Baker et al. (1982, 1985), Daglis and Sarris (1998), and Ono et al. (2010) concluded that heavy ions promote the occurrence of substorms. On the contrary, Lennartsson et al. (1993), Kistler et al. (2006), Nosé et al. (2009), and Liu et al. (2013) argued that the substorm occurrence is not related to the large abundance of heavy ions in the plasma sheet. Numerical simulations have examined the role of heavy ions in substorm occurrence. Using the multi-fluid Lyon-Fedder-Mobarry (MFLFM) global MHD code, Wiltberger et al. (2010), Brambles et al. (2011), and Ouellette et al. (2013) proposed a positive feedback loop in the magnetosphere-ionosphere system where the O+ ion outflow from the ionosphere facilitates the development of the next substorm. From numerical calculation using the multi-fluid Block-Adaptive Tree Solar-wind Roe Upwind Scheme (BATS-R-US) global MHD code, Yu and Ridley (2013) found opposite effects between the different ionospheric sources: O+ ions from the dayside cusp facilitate substorms, whereas those from the nightside auroral region hinder the development of substorms. As shown here, the influence of heavy ions on substorm dynamics is still a controversial issue and has not been determined definitively. Review papers on this issue are also recently published (Wiltberger 2014; Kistler 2015).
From the statistical analysis of an unprecedentedly long-term dataset covering almost two solar cycles (~23 years), the present study provides additional observational evidence that heavy ions work to prevent the occurrence of substorms. However, more theoretical studies are needed to comprehensively understand the role of heavy ions in the onset of substorms.
The Geotail/EPIC data are provided by A. T. Y. Lui and R. W. McEntire at the Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory, and are available at http://sd-www.jhuapl.edu/Geotail. The Mg II index is provided by the University of Bremen and is available at http://www.iup.uni-bremen.de/gome/gomemgii.html. The high-resolution OMNI data are provided by Space Physics Data Facility, Goddard Space Flight Center, and are available at http://omniweb.gsfc.nasa.gov/ow_min.html. The Dst index is provided by the World Data Center for Geomagnetism, Kyoto, and is available at http://wdc.kugi.kyoto-u.ac.jp. We are thankful to Y. Miyashita, K. Keika, and A. Ieda for their helpful comments. We thank S. R. Nylund for his help in processing the Geotail/EPIC data. This study was supported by the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology (MEXT), Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (B) (Grant 25287127).
The author declares that he has no competing interests.
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.
- Baker DN, Hones W Jr, Young DT, Birn J (1982) The possible role of ionospheric oxygen in the initiation and development of plasma sheet instabilities. Geophys Res Lett 9:1337–1340. doi:10.1029/GL009i012p01337 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Baker DN, Fritz TA, Birn J, Lennartsson W, Wilken B, Kroehl HW (1985) The role of heavy ionospheric ions in the localization of substorm disturbances on March 22, 1979: CDAW 6. J Geophys Res 90:1273–1281. doi:10.1029/JA090iA02p01273 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Balan N, Bailey GJ, Jenkins B, Rao PB, Moffett RJ (1994) Variations of ionospheric ionization and related solar fluxes during an intense solar cycle. J Geophys Res 99:2243–2253. doi:10.1029/93JA02099 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Bevington PR, Robinson DK (1992) Data reduction and error analysis for the physical sciences, 2nd edn. McGrwa-Hill, Boston, pp 198–201Google Scholar
- Bowman BR, Tobiska WK, Kendra MJ (2008) The thermospheric semiannual density response to solar EUV heating. J Atmos Sol-Terr Phys 70:1482–1496. doi:10.1016/j.jastp.2008.04.020 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Brambles OJ, Lotko W, Zhang B, Wiltberger M, Lyon J, Strangeway RJ (2011) Magnetosphere sawtooth oscillations induced by ionospheric outflow. Science 332:1183–1186. doi:10.1126/science.1202869 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Daglis IA (1997) The role of magnetosphere-ionosphere coupling in magnetic storm dynamics. In: Tsurutani BT (ed) Magnetic Storms, Geophys Monogr Ser, vol 98. AGU, Washington DC, pp 107–116View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Daglis IA, Sarris ET (1998) Comment on “Experimental investigation of possible geomagnetic feedback from energetic (0.1 to 16 keV) terrestrial O+ ions in the magnetotail current sheet” by Lennartsson OW, Klumpar DM, Shelley EG. Quinn JM. J Geophys Res 103:29545–29548. doi:10.1029/98JA02268 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Floyd L, Newmark J, Cook J, Herring L, McMullin D (2005) Solar EUV and UV spectral irradiances and solar indices. J Atmos Sol-Terr Phys 67:3–15. doi:10.1016/j.jastp.2004.07.013 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hamilton DC, Gloeckler G, Ipavich FM, Wilken B, Stuedemann W (1988) Ring current development during the great geomagnetic storm of February 1986. J Geophys Res 93:14343–14355. doi:10.1029/JA093iA12p14343 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Heath DF, Schlesinger BM (1986) The Mg 280-nm doublet as a monitor of changes in solar ultraviolet irradiance. J Geophys Res 91:8672–8868. doi:10.1029/JD091iD08p08672 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hsu TS, McPherron RL (2003) Occurrence frequencies of IMF triggered and nontriggered substorms. J Geophys Res 108:1307. doi:10.1029/2002JA009442 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kistler LM (2015) The impact of O+ on magnetotail dynamics. In: Magnetosphere-ionosphere coupling in the solar system, geophys monogr ser. AGU, Washington DC (in press)Google Scholar
- Kistler LM, Mouikis CG, Cao X, Frey H, Klecker B, Dandouras I, Korth A, Marcucci MF, Lundin R, McCarthy M, Friedel R, Lucek E (2006) Ion composition and pressure changes in storm time and nonstorm substorms in the vicinity of the near-Earth neutral line. J Geophys Res 111:A11222. doi:10.1029/2006JA011939 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Lennartsson W (1989) Energetic (0.1- to 16-keV/e) magnetospheric ion composition at different levels of solar F10.7. J Geophys Res 94:3600–3610. doi:10.1029/JA094iA04p03600 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Lennartsson OW, Klumpar DM, Shelley EG, Quinn JM (1993) Experimental investigation of possible geomagnetic feedback from energetic (0.1 to 16 keV) terrestrial O+ ions in the magnetotail current sheet. J Geophys Res 98:19443–19454. doi:10.1029/93JA01991 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Liu Y, Kistler LM, Mouikis CG, Klecker B, Dandouras I (2013) Heavy ion effects on substorm loading and unloading in the Earth’s magnetotail. J Geophys Res 118:2101–2112. doi:10.1002/jgra.50240 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Lui ATY, Chang CL, Mankofsky A, Wong HK, Winske D (1991) A cross-field current instability for substorm expansions. J Geophys Res 96:11389–11401. doi:10.1029/91JA00892 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Lyons LR (1995) A new theory for magnetospheric substorms. J Geophys Res 100:19069–19081. doi:10.1029/95JA01344 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Nishida A (1994) The GEOTAIL mission. Geophys Res Lett 21:2871–2874. doi:10.1029/94GL01223 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Nosé M, Iyemori T, Takeda M, Kamei T, Milling DK, Orr D, Singer HJ, Worthington EW, Sumitomo N (1998) Automated detection of Pi2 pulsations using wavelet analysis: 1. Method and an application for substorm monitoring. Earth Planets Space 50:773–783. doi:10.1186/BF03352169 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Nosé M, McEntire RW, Christon SP (2003) Change of the plasma sheet ion composition during magnetic storm development observed by the Geotail spacecraft. J Geophys Res 108:1201. doi:10.1029/2004JA010930 Google Scholar
- Nosé M, Taguchi S, Hosokawa K, Christon SP, McEntire RW, Moore TE, Collier MR (2005) Overwhelming O+ contribution to the plasma sheet energy density during the October 2003 superstorm: Geotail/EPIC and IMAGE/LENA observations. J Geophys Res 110:A09S24. doi:10.1029/2004JA010930 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Nosé M, Ieda A, Christon SP (2009) Geotail observations of plasma sheet ion composition over 16 years: on variations of average plasma ion mass and O+ triggering substorm model. J Geophys Res 114:A07223. doi:10.1029/2009JA014203 Google Scholar
- Ono Y, Christon SP, Frey HU, Lui ATY (2010) Distribution of O+ ions in the plasma sheet and locations of substorm onsets. J Geophys Res 115:A09220. doi:10.1029/2009JA015138 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ouellette JE, Brambles OJ, Lyon JG, Lotko W, Rogers BN (2013) Properties of outflow-driven sawtooth substorms. J Geophys Res 118:3223–3232. doi:10.1002/jgra.50309 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Pulkkinen TI, Ganushkina NY, Baker DN, Turner NE, Fennell JF, Roeder J, Fritz TA, Grande M, Kellett B, Kettmann G (2001) Ring current ion composition during solar minimum and rising solar activity: Polar/CAMMICE/MICS results. J Geophys Res 106:19131–19148. doi:10.1029/2000JA003036 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Roux A, Perraut S, Robert P, Morane A, Pedersen A, Korth A, Kremser G, Aparicio D, Rodgers D, Pellinen R (1991) Plasma sheet instability related to the westward traveling surge. J Geophys Res 96:17697–17714. doi:10.1029/91JA01106 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Snow M, Weber M, Machol J, Viereck R, Richard E (2014) Comparison of Magnesium II core-to-wing ratio observations during solar minimum 23/24. J Space Weather Space Clim 4:A04. doi:10.1051/swsc/2014001 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Stokholm M, Balsiger H, Geiss J, Rosenbauer H, Young DT (1989) Variations of the magnetospheric ion number densities near geostationary orbit with solar activity. Ann Geophys 7:69–76Google Scholar
- Viereck R, Puga L, McMullin D, Judge D, Weber M, Tobiska WK (2001) The Mg II index: a proxy for solar EUV. Geophy Res Lett 28:1343–1346. doi:10.1029/2000GL012551 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Williams DJ, McEntire RW, Schlemm C II, Lui ATY, Gloeckler G, Christon SP, Gliem F (1994) Geotail energetic particles and ion composition instrument. J Geomagn Geoelectr 46:39–57. doi:10.5636/jgg.46.39 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Wiltberger M (2014) Review of global simulation studies of effect of ionospheric outflow on magnetosphere-ionosphere system dynamics. In: Keiling A, Jackman CM, Delamere PA (eds) Magnetotails in the solar system, geophys monogr ser, vol 207. AGU, Washington DC, pp 373–392Google Scholar
- Wiltberger M, Lotko W, Lyon JG, Damiano P, Merkin V (2010) Influence of cusp O+ outflow on magnetotail dynamics in a multifluid MHD model of the magnetosphere. J Geophys Res 115:A00J05. doi:10.1029/2010JA015579 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Young DT, Balsiger H, Geiss J (1982) Correlations of magnetospheric ion composition with geomagnetic and solar activity. J Geophys Res 87:9077–9096. doi:10.1029/JA087iA11p09077 View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yu Y, Ridley AJ (2013) Exploring the influence of ionospheric O+ outflow on magnetospheric dynamics: dependence on the source location. J Geophys Res 118:1711–1722. doi:10.1029/2012JA018411 View ArticleGoogle Scholar