Official Journal of the Asia Oceania Geosciences Society (AOGS)
From: Households’ vulnerability assessment: empirical evidence from cyclone-prone area of Bangladesh
Social vulnerability | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Indicators | Overall n (%) | Kalmegha n (%) | Patharghata n (%) | p-value | Cramer’s V or Phi (φ)# |
Family size Less than 4 4 to 6 More than 6 | 131 (33.80) 224 (57.70) 33 (8.50) | 64 (33.70) 100 (52.60) 26 (13.70) | 67 (33.80) 124 (62.60) 7 (3.50) | 0.001** | 0.19 |
Family type Single Nuclear Extended | 24 (6.20) 246 (63.40) 118 (30.40) | 12 (6.30) 112 (58.90) 66 (34.70) | 12 (6.10) 134 (67.70) 52 (26.30) | 0.177 | 0.09 |
Households with children Yes No | 304 (78.40) 84 (21.60) | 152 (80.00) 38 (20.00) | 152 (76.80) 46 (23.20) | 0.443 | 0.04 |
Households with older adults (> 60 years) Yes No | 128 (33.00) 260 (67.00) | 68 (35.80) 122 (64.20) | 60 (30.30) 138 (69.70) | 0.298 | 0.06 |
Household head's educational attainment No Primary Secondary School Higher Secondary and above | 181 (46.60) 164 (42.30) 27 (7.00) 16 (4.10) | 87 (45.80) 82 (43.20) 10 (5.30) 11 (5.80) | 94 (47.50) 82 (41.40) 17 (8.60) 5 (2.50) | 0.243 | 0.10 |
Family members with higher education level (Higher Secondary and above) Yes No | 66 (17.00) 322 (83.00) | 32 (16.80) 158 (83.20) | 34 (17.20) 164 (82.80) | 1.00 | 0.00 |
Households residing periods in the community (in years) Less than 10 10 to 20 20 to 30 30 to 40 More than 40 | 28 (7.20) 39 (10.10) 63 (16.20) 110 (28.40) 148 (38.10) | 8 (4.20) 11 (5.80) 28 (14.70) 47 (24.70) 96 (50.50) | 20 (10.10) 28 (14.10) 35 (17.70) 63 (31.80) 52 (26.30) | 0.000*** | 0.27 |
Households with disabled members Yes No | 30 (7.70) 358 (92.30) | 11 (5.80) 179 (94.20) | 19 (9.60) 179 (90.40) | 0.225 | 0.07 |
Households with chronically ill members Yes No | 92 (23.70) 296 (76.30) | 46 (24.20) 144 (75.80) | 46 (23.20) 152 (76.80) | 0.915 | 0.01 |
Economic Vulnerability | |||||
Indicators | Overall n (%) | Kalmegha n (%) | Patharghata n (%) | p-value | Cramer’s V or Phi (φ)# |
Occupation of household head Government/Private Job Trade and commerce Agriculture Daily wagers Unemployed | 21 (5.40) 49 (12.60) 201 (51.80) 88 (22.70) 29 (7.50) | 10 (5.30) 34 (17.90) 79 (41.60) 50 (26.30) 17 (8.90) | 11 (5.60) 15 (7.60) 122 (61.60) 38 (19.20) 12 (6.10) | 0.000*** | 0.22 |
A secondary source of income Yes No | 38 (9.80) 350 (90.20) | 17 (8.90) 173 (91.10) | 21 (10.60) 177 (89.40) | 0.705 | 0.03 |
Earning members of the households other than the household head Yes No | 119 (30.70) 269 (69.30) | 63 (33.20) 127 (66.80) | 56 (28.30) 142 (71.70) | 0.352 | 0.05 |
Dependency ratio (dependents to total household size) Less than 0.41 0.41 to 1.34 1.35 to 2.29 More than 2.29 | 105 (27.10) 221 (57.00) 50 (12.90) 12 (3.10) | 55 (28.90) 108 (56.80) 22 (11.60) 5 (2.60) | 50 (25.30) 113 (57.10) 28 (14.10) 7 (3.50) | 0.743 | 0.06 |
Average annual household's income Less than 50,000 50,000–100,000 100,000–150,000 More than 150,000 | 48 (12.40) 109 (28.10) 136 (35.10) 95 (24.50) | 21 (11.10) 51 (26.80) 70 (36.80) 48 (25.30) | 27 (13.60) 58 (29.30) 66 (33.30) 47 (23.70) | 0.762 | 0.05 |
Outside-the-community-working family members Yes No | 35 (9.00) 353 (91.00) | 18 (9.50) 172 (90.50) | 17 (8.60) 181 (91.40) | 0.898 | 0.01 |
Easily convertible (to cash) assets Yes No | 214 (55.20) 174 (44.80) | 102 (53.70) 88 (46.30) | 112 (56.60) 86 (43.40) | 0.639 | 0.03 |
If a cyclone occurred today, would you be able to cover the costs? Yes No | 35 (9.00) 353 (91.00) | 14 (7.40) 176 (92.60) | 21 (10.60) 177 (89.40) | 0.349 | 0.06 |
Physical Vulnerability | Â | ||||
Indicators | Overall n (%) | Kalmegha n (%) | Patharghata n (%) | p-value | Cramer’s V or Phi (φ)# |
Age of house (in years) Less than 5 5 to 10 10 to 15 More than 15 | 52 (13.40) 61 (15.70) 177 (45.60) 98 (25.30) | 18 (9.50) 31 (16.30) 88 (46.30) 53 (27.90) | 34 (17.20) 30 (15.20) 89 (44.90) 45 (22.70) | 0.142 | 0.12 |
Construction materials of household Katcha (Tin-shed, Mud) Semi Pacca (Mixed with tin and brick) Pacca (Brick, Cement) | 348 (89.70) 27 (7.00) 13 (3.40) | 171 (90.00) 10 (5.30) 9 (4.70) | 177 (89.40) 17 (8.60) 4 (2.00) | 0.159 | 0.09 |
House elevation from flat land Yes No | 382 (98.50) 6 (1.50) | 188 (98.90) 2 (1.10) | 194 (98.00) 4 (2.00) | 0.685 | 0.04 |
Distance between households and nearest cyclone shelter (in km) Less than 1 1 to 5 5 to 10 | 148 (38.10) 228 (58.80) 12 (3.10) | 54 (28.40) 124 (65.30) 12 (6.30) | 94 (47.50) 104 (52.50) 0 (0.00) | 0.000*** | 0.25 |
Distance between nearest medical facility and households (in km) Less than 1 1 to 5 5 to 10 | 63 (16.20) 286 (73.70) 39 (10.10) | 14 (7.40) 165 (86.80) 11 (5.80) | 49 (24.70) 121 (61.10) 28 (14.10) | 0.000*** | 0.29 |
Condition of the closest cyclone shelter's WASH Satisfied Neutral Dissatisfied | 153 (39.40) 91 (23.50) 144 (37.10) | 73 (38.40) 57 (30.00) 60 (31.60) | 80 (40.40) 34 (17.20) 84 (42.40) | 0.007** | 0.16 |
Conditions of the nearest medical facility Satisfied Neutral Dissatisfied | 157 (40.50) 47 (12.10) 184 (47.40) | 66 (34.70) 28 (14.70) 96 (50.50) | 91 (46.00) 19 (9.60) 88 (44.40) | 0.053 | 0.12 |
Household's access to proper sanitation Yes No | 42 (10.80) 346 (89.20) | 23 (12.10) 167 (87.90) | 19 (9.60) 179 (90.40) | 0.528 | 0.04 |
Electricity to the household Yes No | 363 (93.60) 25 (6.40) | 184 (96.80) 6 (3.20) | 179 (90.40) 19 (9.60) | 0.017* | 0.13 |
Source of communication (Radio, TV, Mobile) Yes No | 373 (96.10) 15 (3.90) | 181 (95.30) 9 (4.70) | 192 (97.00) 6 (3.00) | 0.543 | 0.04 |
Institutional Vulnerability | Â | ||||
Indicators | Overall n (%) | Kalmegha n (%) | Patharghata n (%) | p-value | Cramer’s V or Phi (φ)# |
Understand early warning Yes No | 143 (36.90) 245 (63.10) | 71 (37.40) 119 (62.60) | 72 (36.40) 126 (63.60) | 0.920 | 0.01 |
Knowledge about cyclone Yes No | 58 (14.90) 330 (85.10) | 22 (11.60) 168 (88.40) | 36 (18.20) 162 (81.80) | 0.093 | 0.09 |
Knowledge about evacuation routes Yes No | 358 (92.30) 30 (7.70) | 177 (93.20) 13 (6.80) | 181 (91.40) 17 (8.60) | 0.651 | 0.03 |
Frequency of public-awareness campaigns, exercises, and training Often Rarely Never | 34 (8.80) 85 (21.90) 269 (69.30) | 12 (6.30) 31 (16.30) 147 (77.40) | 22 (11.10) 54 (27.30) 122 (61.60) | 0.003** | 0.17 |
Received government relief after cyclone Yes No | 299 (77.10) 89 (22.90) | 141 (74.20) 49 (25.80) | 158 (79.80) 40 (20.20) | 0.235 | 0.07 |
Received humanitarian aid from NGO/INGO after cyclone Yes No | 243 (62.60) 145 (37.40) | 120 (63.20) 70 (36.80) | 123 (62.10) 75 (37.90) | 0.915 | 0.01 |
Unequal relief distribution Yes No | 276 (71.10) 112 (28.90) | 132 (69.50) 58 (30.50) | 144 (72.70) 54 (27.30) | 0.552 | 0.04 |
Unequal humanitarian aid distribution Yes No | 177 (45.60) 211 (54.40) | 78 (41.10) 112 (58.90) | 99 (50.00) 99 (50.00) | 0.095 | 0.09 |
Attitudinal vulnerability | |||||
Indicators | Overall n (%) | Kalmegha n (%) | Patharghata n (%) | p-value | Cramer’s V or Phi (φ)# |
Community cooperation during cyclones Poor Moderate Good | 90 (23.20) 56 (14.40) 242 (62.40) | 39 (20.50) 35 (18.40) 116 (61.10) | 51 (25.80) 21 (10.60) 126 (63.60) | 0.069 | 0.12 |
Communication with local government over the year Yes No | 187 (48.20) 201 (51.80) | 102 (53.70) 88 (46.30) | 85 (42.90) 113 (57.10) | 0.044 | 0.11 |
Households feel afraid of cyclones Not worried at all Worried Very much worried | 46 (11.90) 158 (40.70) 184 (47.40) | 20 (10.50) 80 (42.10) 90 (47.40) | 26 (13.10) 78 (39.40) 94 (47.50) | 0.694 | 0.04 |
Trust in government High Low Moderate | 83 (21.40) 220 (56.70) 85 (21.90) | 30 (15.80) 115 (60.50) 45 (23.70) | 53 (26.80) 105 (53.00) 40 (20.20) | 0.031* | 0.13 |
Evacuation behavior during cyclone Positive Negative | 324 (83.50) 64 (16.50) | 150 (78.90) 40 (21.10) | 174 (87.90) 24 (12.10) | 0.025* | 0.12 |
Environmental Vulnerability | Â | ||||
Indicators | Overall n (%) | Kalmegha n (%) | Patharghata n (%) | p-value | Cramer’s V or Phi (φ)# |
Source of drinking water Ground water Surface water | 16 (4.10) 372 (95.90) | 16 (8.40) 174 (91.60) | 0 (0.00) 198 (100.00) | 0.000*** | 0.21 |
The salinity of the drinking water Yes No | 16 (4.10) 372 (95.90) | 16 (8.40) 174 (91.60) | 0 (0.00) 198 (100.00) | 0.000*** | 0.21 |
Trees can act as a natural barrier Yes No | 191 (49.20) 197 (50.80) | 79 (41.60) 111 (58.40) | 112 (56.60) 86 (43.40) | 0.004** | 0.15 |